12 quotes
Lessons from History and Military Miscalculations
President John F. Kennedy
You know, last summer, I read a book, ]. I wish every man on that blockade line had read that book. It's World War I, there's thirteen million killed; it was all because the militaries of both alliances believed they were so highly attuned to one another's movements and dispositions, they could predict one another's intentions, but all their theories were based on the last war. And the world and technology had changed, and those lessons were no longer valid, but it was all they knew, so the orders went out, and couldn't be rescinded. And your man in the field, his family at home; they couldn't even tell you the reasons why their lives were being destroyed. But why couldn't they stop it? What could they have done? Here we are, fifty years later. Think if one of their ships resists the inspection, and we shoot out its rudder, and board, they shoot down one of our planes in response, so we bomb their anti-aircraft sites, and in response to that, they attack Berlin...so we invade Cuba...and they fire their missiles...and we fire ours.
[The night prior to the beginning of the U.S. Navy's military "quarantine" of Cuba; [w:The Guns of August|The Guns of August]
Exploring Options in Crisis Decision-Making
Robert Kennedy
No, no, NO! Now there is more than one option here, and if one isn't occurring to us, it's because we haven't thought hard enough.
John McCone
Bobby, sometimes there is only one right choice, and you thank God when it's so clear!
Kennedy
You're talking a sneak attack. How will that make us look? A big country blasting a little country to the Stone Age. Yeah, we'll be everyone's favorites.
Dean Acheson
Come on Bobby, that's naïve. This is the real world. You know that better than anybody.
John McCone
And you weren't so ethically particular when we were talking about options for removing Castro over at CIA.
Crisis Management During Nuclear Tensions
President Kennedy
Dean, how does this all play out?
Dean Acheson
Your first step sir, will be to demand that the Soviet withdraw the missiles within 12 to 24 hours. They will refuse. When they do you will order the strikes, followed by the invasion. They will resist and be overrun. They will retaliate against another target somewhere else in the world, most likely Berlin. We will honor our treaty commitments and resist them there, defeating them per our plans.
Kennedy
Those plans call for the use of nuclear weapons. So what is the next step?
Acheson
Hopefully cooler heads will prevail before we reach the next step.
Concerns Over Decision-Making and Leadership Weakness
Dean Acheson
What happened in there?
Gen. Maxwell Taylor
I thought he was going to give us his decision.
McGeorge Bundy
Look, I know them. They just need to make sure there's no other way. They'll get there.
Acheson
Remember, the ] was one of the architects of ]. There's only one responsible choice here. So, let's hope appeasement doesn't run in families. I fear weakness does.
[[w:Joseph P. Kennedy|Kennedys' father; [w:Munich Agreement|Munich]
Leadership Under Pressure in Crisis Moments
Kenny O'Donnell
You know, call me Irish, but I don't believe in "cooler heads prevailing.
President Kennedy
You know, they think I froze in there.
O'Donnell
You didn't freeze. You did what you were supposed to do, you stayed out of the corner. You didn't decide.
Kennedy
Acheson's scenario is unacceptable, and he's got more experience than anybody.
O'Donnell
There is no expert on the subject, there is no wise old man. There's... shit, there's just us.
Kennedy
The thing is that Acheson's right. Talk alone's not gonna accomplish anything.
O'Donnell
Well, let's bomb the shit out of em! Everybody wants to. Even you, I mean, even me, right? It sure would feel good.
Authority of the Commander in Chief
President John F. Kennedy
I am the commander in chief of the United States, and I say when we go to war!
Reframing Conflict Through New Diplomatic Language
Robert McNamara
This is not a blockade. This is language. A new vocabulary, the likes of which the world has never seen! This is President Kennedy communicating with Secretary Khrushchev!
Tensions Rise During Cuban Missile Crisis
Kenny O'Donnell
I got a bad feeling about what's going on in there!
President Kennedy
In the morning I'm taking charge of the blockade from the situation room and MacNamara is gonna set up shop at the flagpot at the Pentagon and keep an eye on things there.
O'Donnell
Good. Because you've got armed boarders climbing onto Soviet ships, and shots being fired across bows!
Kennedy
I know. I know.
O'Donnell
Well, what about these low level flights?
Kennedy
We need the flights.
O'Donnell
They're starting them when?
Kennedy
An hour.
O'Donnell
An hour. You realize what you're getting yourself in for?
Kennedy
Kenny, no, we need the flights, because the minute that first missile becomes operational we gotta go in there and destroy it.
O'Donnell
Fair enough, but Castro's on alert and we're flying attack planes over their sites, on the deck! There's no way for them to know we're carrying cameras not bombs.
Kennedy
God damn it!
O'Donnell
They're gonna be shot at, plain and simple.
Soviet Missile Threat Revealed in Cuba Crisis
President Kennedy
Okay - let's have it.
NPIC Photo Interpreter
Gentlemen, as most of you now know, a U-2 over Cuba Sunday morning took a series of disturbing photographs. Our analysis at NPIC indicates that the Soviet Union has followed up its conventional weapons build-up in Cuba with the introduction of surface-to-surface, medium-range ballistic missiles, or MRBMs. Our official estimate at this time is that the missile system is the SS-4 Sandal'. We do not believe that the missiles are as yet operational. Iron Bark reports that the SS-4 can deliver a three-megaton nuclear weapon 1,000 miles. So far we've identified 32 missiles serviced by about 3,400 men, undoubtedly all Soviet personnel. Our cities and military installations in the southeast as far north as Washington, D.C., are in range of these weapons, and in the event of a launch would have only five minutes warning.
General Marshall Carter
Five minutes, gentlemen.
Gen. Maxwell Taylor
In those five minutes, they could kill 80 million Americans - and destroy a significant percentage of our bomber bases, degrading our retaliatory options. The Joint Chiefs consensus, Mr. President, is that this signals a major doctrinal shift in Soviet thinking - to a first-strike policy. It is a massively destabilizing move.
Robert Kennedy
How long until they're operational?
NPIC Photo Interpreter
General Taylor can answer that question better than I can.
Taylor
GMAC - Guided Missiles Intelligence Committee - estimates 10-14 days. A crash program could limit that time. However, I must stress that there may be more missiles...that we don't know about. We'll need more U-2 coverage.
President Kennedy
Gentlemen, I want first reactions here. Assuming for the moment that Khruschev has NOT gone off the deep end - and intends to start World War Three - what are we looking at?
Dean Rusk
Mr. President, I believe my team is in agreement. If we permit the introduction of nuclear missiles to a Soviet satellite nation in our hemisphere, the diplomatic consequences will be too terrible to contemplate. The Russians are trying to show the world they can do whatever they want, wherever they want, and we're powerless to stop them. If they succeed...
Robert Kennedy
It'll be ] all over again.
[[w:Munich Agreement|Munich]
Rusk
Yes. Appeasement only makes the aggressor more aggressive. And the Soviets will be emboldened to push us even harder. Now we must remove the missiles one way or another. Now it seems to me the options are either some combination of international pressure & action on our part, until they give in, or...we hit them. An air strike.
Shared Consequences in Crisis Situations
Gen. Curtis LeMay
You're in a pretty bad fix, Mr. President.
President Kennedy
What did you say?
[wonders at remark and looks back at LeMay]
LeMay
You're in a pretty bad fix.
Kennedy
Well, maybe you haven't noticed you're in it with me.
Crisis Negotiations During the Cuban Missile Crisis
Robert Kennedy
At this moment the President is accepting the terms of Secretary Khrushchev's letter of Friday night. If the Soviet Union halts construction immediately, removes the missiles, and submits to UN inspections, the United States will pledge to never invade Cuba, or to aid others in that enterprise.
Anatoly Dobrynin
If your Jupiter missiles in Turkey were removed also, such an accommodation could be reached.
RFK
That's not possible. The United States cannot agree to such terms under threat. Any belief to the contrary was in error.
Dobrynin
You want war?
RFK
However...while there can be no quid pro quo on this issue, the United States can offer a private assurance. Now our Jupiter missiles in Turkey are obsolete, and have been scheduled for withdrawal for some time. This withdrawal should take place within, say, six months. Of course any public disclosure of this assurance would negate the deal, and produce the most stringent denials from our government.
[RFK makes a frustrated gesture; Dobrynin reaches for his briefcase as if to leave]
Dobrynin
This private assurance, represents the word of the highest authority?
RFK
Yes.
Dobrynin
And it can be relayed beyond Comrade Khrushchev's ears, to the top circles of my government?
RFK
Our pledge can be relayed to any government official Secretary Khrushchev sees fit to satisfy. With the caveat that it is not to be made public in any way, shape, or form. And we must have an answer tomorrow, at the latest. I cannot stress this point enough.
Dobrynin
Tomorrow?
RFK
Tomorrow.
[firmly]
Dobrynin
Then, you must excuse me, and permit me to relay the substance of our discussion to my superiors.
[stands to leave]
RFK
Of course.
Dobrynin
We have heard stories that some of your military men wish for war.
Dobrynin
You are a good man. Your brother is a good man. I assure you there are other good men. Let us hope the will of good men is enough to counter the terrible strength of this thing that was put in motion.
[Puts his hand on RFK's shoulder]
Orders for Avoiding Combat in Crisis
Kenny O'Donnell
The president has instructed me to pass along an order to you. You are not to get shot down.
Commander William B. Ecker
Uh, we'll do our best, sir.
O'Donnell
I don't think you understand me, Commander. You are not to get shot down under any circumstances. Whatever happens up there, you were not shot at. Mechanical failures are fine, crashing into mountains fine. But you and your men are not to be shot at, fired at, or launched upon.
Ecker
Excuse me sir, what the hell is going on here?
O'Donnell
Commander, if you are fired upon, the President will be forced to attack the sites that fire on you. He doesn't want to have to do that. It's very important that he doesn't, or things could get very badly out of control.